# Qustul incense burner and the debate over Nubian kingship (c. 3300 BCE)

URL: https://allhistories.com/sudan/timeline/-3300-qustul-incense-burner-and-the-debate-over-nubian-kingship
Location: Qustul, near Abu Simbel, Egypt-Sudan border
Themes: main-event

In the Qustul cemetery near Wadi Halfa, the excavators of the 1960s uncovered tombs of A-Group leaders and an incense burner carved with a boat, a ruler wearing a white crown and a falcon, motifs also found in early Egyptian royal art. The burner was found in a tomb in a cemetery that held several rich burials. The tomb belonged to a cemetery used by several generations of A-Group leaders, now flooded by Lake Nasser. The discovery led some scholars to argue that kingship first arose in Nubia, a claim summed up by the idea of a Nubian origin for pharaonic symbols. Most Egyptologists reject this, pointing out that the iconography is also found in Upper Egypt and that dating suggests parallel development. The debate continues and shows the intensity of interactions. The burner was discovered by an Oriental Institute team during the Nubian salvage campaign and published by Bruce Williams, who championed the Nubian hypothesis. No single named ruler is documented for the lands of historic Sudan at this date. The period is represented in the rulers file by the placeholder entry 'Palaeolithic to Neolithic communities of the Nile valley', so the event belongs to the history of Nile valley communities and polities rather than a documented head of state. The Qustul burner is central to modern debates about how African and Egyptian cultures influenced each other and highlights the political sophistication of A-Group chiefs. The Qustul burner is central to modern debates about how African and Egyptian cultures influenced one another and highlights the political sophistication of A-Group chiefs.

## Why it matters
A single carved burner reshaped debates about who invented kingship.

Ruler at the Time: [Palaeolithic to Neolithic communities of the Nile valley](https://allhistories.com/sudan/rulers/palaeolithic-to-neolithic-communities-of-the-nile-valley)

## Sources
- [Qustul incense burner](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qustul_incense_burner)
- [History of Sudan](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Sudan)
- [A-Group culture](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-Group_culture)

