# Byans Boundary and the Origins of the Kalapani Dispute (1817)

URL: https://allhistories.com/nepal/timeline/1817-byans-boundary-and-the-origins-of-the-kalapani-dispute
Location: Byans valley, Kalapani
Themes: Borders, Kalapani

In 1817 the Nepalese governor Bam Shah claimed villages in the Byans valley that, he argued, lay east of the river Kali. The British conceded Changru and Tinkar, then rejected a further claim to Kuti and Nabhi on the grounds that the main stream of the Kali rose from the Kalapani springs. Lord Moira rejected the larger claim in September 1817, according to Wikipedia. The Sugauli Treaty gave up all lands west of the river Kali without saying exactly which stream was the Kali. Nepalese officials argued that the western headwater, the Kuthi Yankti, was the main river, while British surveyors, relying on local opinion, treated the eastern stream from Kalapani as the main branch. The Byans district was therefore divided between the two states. The question lay dormant for nearly two centuries. It returned in the late twentieth century as the Kalapani–Limpiyadhura–Lipulekh dispute, and Nepal's 2020 political map included the area claimed in 1817. India disputes Nepal's interpretation and says the Kali begins only after the Kalapani streams join. The matter remains unresolved and is handled through diplomatic talks. At this point in the timeline (1817), the Kingdom of Nepal was under King Rajendra Bikram Shah (20 November 1816 – 15 September 1846), alongside Mukhtiyar (prime minister) Bhimsen Thapa (1806 – 14 June 1837) and Queen Lalita Tripura Sundari Devi as regent (c. 1816 – c. 1832).

## Why it matters
The 1817 settlement of Byans is the root of a border dispute between Nepal and India that remains open today.

Ruler at the Time: [Rajendra Bikram Shah (until Kot massacre)](https://allhistories.com/nepal/rulers/rajendra-bikram-shah-until-kot-massacre)

## Sources
- [Wikipedia — Kalapani territory](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalapani_territory)
- [Wikipedia — Treaty of Sugauli](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Sugauli)

