# International Court of Justice awards Kasikili/Sedudu Island to Botswana (13 December 1999)

URL: https://allhistories.com/namibia/timeline/1999-international-court-of-justice-awards-kasikili-sedudu-island-to-botswana
Location: The Hague, Netherlands
Themes: main-event

On 13 December 1999 the International Court of Justice gave judgment in the case concerning Kasikili/Sedudu Island between Botswana and Namibia, according to Wikipedia. By 11 votes to 4 it found that the boundary follows the line of deepest soundings in the northern channel of the Chobe River and that the island is part of Botswana. The two states had referred the dispute by a special agreement transmitted on 17 May 1996. The 1890 Heligoland-Zanzibar Treaty placed the boundary in the "main channel" of the Chobe but did not define it. Botswana argued that the main channel lay north of the island, and Namibia that it lay south. The Court weighed depth, width, flow, bed profile and navigability. It rejected Namibia's alternative claim, based on use of the island by the Subia people, for lack of evidence of state authority. The judgment also decided, unanimously, that nationals and vessels of both states must have equal treatment in the channels around the island, consistent with the May 1992 Kasane Communiqué. The Court sat with fifteen judges, and four dissented: Weeramantry, Fleischhauer, Parra-Aranguren and Rezek. The ruling confirmed that the island lay on the Botswana side of the boundary, while leaving open navigation for both countries. At this point in the timeline (1999), Sam Nujoma (21 Mar 1990 – 21 Mar 2005) was the first President of independent Namibia, in office from 21 March 1990, and led the country through its first fifteen years; Prime Minister Hage Geingob (21 Mar 1990 – 28 Aug 2002) led the government.

## Why it matters
The ruling settled a colonial-era boundary question by law, and was accepted by both states.

Ruler at the Time: [Sam Nujoma](https://allhistories.com/namibia/rulers/sam-nujoma-1990)

## Sources
- [Wikipedia — Sedudu Island case](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kasikili/Sedudu_Island_case)
- [press.un.org — 19991213.icj594.doc](https://press.un.org/en/1999/19991213.icj594.doc.html)
- [Wikipedia — Sedudu Island](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kasikili/Sedudu_Island)

