# Public controversy over the cost of Tarawa (November–December 1943)

URL: https://allhistories.com/kiribati/timeline/1943-public-controversy-over-the-cost-of-tarawa
Location: United States
Themes: main-event

After the battle there was public protest in the United States over the high casualties. Wikipedia records that Holland Smith, the senior Marine commander, compared the losses to Pickett's Charge and later wrote that Tarawa was not worth the cost. Admiral Nimitz, Admiral Spruance and Colonel Shoup disagreed. Nimitz said the capture had knocked down the front door to Japan's central Pacific defences. Marine Commandant Alexander Vandegrift told Congress that Tarawa was an assault from beginning to end. The sources do not give exact dates for these statements, so the dates are approximate. The debate shaped later operations. The Marshall Islands campaign began about ten weeks after Tarawa, with naval bombardments that lasted a month and used armour-piercing shells, and landing craft were armoured. Public attention was heightened by the release of the documentary With the Marines at Tarawa in March 1944. At this point in the timeline (1943), Vivian Fox-Strangways (Aug 1942 – Nov 1945) was Resident Commissioner of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands, the senior British official in the Gilbert Islands, answerable to the High Commissioner for the Western Pacific; Naoomi Suzuki (1 Sep 1942 – 1 Oct 1945) was among the Japanese commanders in the Gilbert Islands during the Pacific War occupation; Saichiro Tomonari (22 Feb 1943 – Jul 1943) was among the Japanese commanders in the Gilbert Islands during the Pacific War occupation.

## Why it matters
The controversy forced the American military to adapt its amphibious methods. It shows how the battle became a lasting debate about the human cost of island assaults.

Ruler at the Time: [Vivian Fox-Strangways](https://allhistories.com/kiribati/rulers/vivian-fox-strangways-31)

## Sources
- [Wikipedia — Battle of Tarawa](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tarawa)
- [Wikipedia — Operation Galvanic](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Galvanic)

